Help us improve this website
← Press articles on Bram Stoker and Dracula

Press archive

The censorship of fiction

31 October 1908 · Dominion

Bram Stoker Estate account · Original source: English

Estate summary

The Dominion reports R. A. Scott-James’s objection to Bram’s argument for censoring fiction. Drawing on a discussion in the Daily News and on G. K. Chesterton, it asks why sexual content should be treated as uniquely harmful while books encouraging greed, pride or other damaging conduct escape the same standard. Scott-James argues that a censor’s personal judgements could suppress moral criticism and protect popular errors. This is a response to Bram’s Nineteenth Century essay, containing quotations from it, rather than the complete essay itself. It preserves contemporary opposition to a position Bram publicly advocated and helps place his argument within an active literary debate.

Source notes and excerpts

The Dominion reports R. A. Scott-James’s objection to Bram’s argument for censoring fiction. Drawing on a discussion in the Daily News and on G. K. Chesterton, it asks why sexual content should be treated as uniquely harmful while books encouraging greed, pride or other damaging conduct escape the same standard. Scott-James argues that a censor’s personal judgements could suppress moral criticism and protect popular errors. This is a response to Bram’s Nineteenth Century essay, containing quotations from it, rather than the complete essay itself. It preserves contemporary opposition to a position Bram publicly advocated and helps place his argument within an active literary debate.

Related original: Bram’s complete September 1908 essay and original periodical scan.

All three original newspaper image areas visually inspected against OCR. The item quotes and discusses Bram; it is not an article wholly written by him. Original essay and later critic’s contribution must be distinguished before reproducing a complete text. Bram’s original September essay is now held separately and linked from this page.

Original source

Read the original historical reproduction. The source note identifies the provider and any remaining qualifications.

Read the digitised newspaper at Papers Past ↗

Link checked 7 November 2026. Publisher pages open in a new tab.

Saved archive record

The title, date, source details and any Estate summary above are saved on this website, so this record remains available if the publisher’s page changes.

A full copy of this article is not currently held here. Original scans and full texts will be added where available and permitted.

Dominion masthead from 31 October 1908, the same issue as the archived article.
Dominion masthead from 31 October 1908, the same issue as the archived article.Dominion, 31 October 1908. National Library of New Zealand / Papers Past. · Licence